Business as usual

Following the passing of Mr Fleming, Brendan Fleming Limited continues to operate

Fractures

After bruising, fractures are the second most common type of non-accidental injury occurring in children. Therefore, medical professionals are obliged to be on the lookout for signs of child abuse when they treat children who have sustained broken bones especially when a child is non-mobile, or the explanation is not consistent with the presented injury.

Fractures in Children and Non-Accidental Injury Allegations

When a baby or young child suffers a broken bone, medical professionals may investigate whether the injury was accidental or could have been caused deliberately.

Fractures are among the injuries commonly considered in cases involving suspected non-accidental injury (NAI), particularly where a child is not yet mobile or the explanation provided does not appear consistent with the injury.

However, a fracture does not automatically mean that a child has been abused. Accidental injuries, underlying medical conditions and other factors must all be carefully considered before conclusions are reached.

If children’s services have raised concerns about an unexplained fracture, specialist legal advice can help you understand the allegations and protect your position.

Why Do Fractures Raise Concerns About Child Abuse?

Broken bones can occur for many reasons, including accidents, falls and underlying medical conditions.

However, certain circumstances may lead medical professionals to investigate whether a fracture could have been caused non-accidentally.

These include:

  • A fracture in a baby who is not yet crawling or walking
  • An injury where there is no clear explanation of how it occurred
  • A fracture that appears inconsistent with the circumstances described
  • Multiple fractures or fractures at different stages of healing
  • Other injuries, such as unexplained bruising
  • Particular fracture patterns that may raise safeguarding concerns

Where doctors suspect that an injury may have been deliberately inflicted, they may refer the case to children’s services for further investigation.

A safeguarding referral does not establish that a parent has caused an injury. It means that further assessment is considered necessary.

Can Medical Conditions Cause Fractures in Children?

Yes. Some medical conditions can affect bone strength or development, potentially making a child more susceptible to fractures.

Where clinically indicated, doctors may investigate whether an underlying condition could have caused or contributed to an injury.

These conditions may include:

Osteogenesis Imperfecta (Brittle Bone Disease)

Osteogenesis Imperfecta is a genetic condition that affects the strength of bones and can increase the risk of fractures, sometimes following relatively minor trauma.

Vitamin D Deficiency and Rickets

Vitamin D plays an important role in maintaining healthy bones. Severe or prolonged deficiency can cause rickets, a condition that affects bone mineralisation and may increase the risk of fractures.

However, a low Vitamin D level alone does not necessarily explain a particular fracture.

Osteopenia and Metabolic Bone Disorders

Some children, particularly those born prematurely or with certain medical conditions, may have reduced bone mineral density.

Depending on the severity and underlying cause, this can affect bone strength and susceptibility to injury.

Connective Tissue Disorders

Certain connective tissue disorders, including some forms of Ehlers-Danlos syndrome, may be relevant to a child’s wider medical assessment.

However, not all connective tissue disorders cause bone fragility, and the presence of such a condition does not automatically explain a fracture.

Normal Developmental Variations

Children’s developing bones can sometimes display features on medical imaging that require careful interpretation.

An experienced paediatric radiologist can help distinguish normal developmental findings from fractures or other abnormalities.

How Are Fractures Investigated?

Where a child presents with an unexplained fracture, doctors will usually consider the child’s age, developmental stage, medical history and the circumstances surrounding the injury.

Investigations may include:

  • Physical examination
  • X-rays
  • Review of previous medical records
  • Blood tests where an underlying condition is suspected
  • Specialist paediatric assessments
  • Additional imaging where appropriate

In cases involving suspected non-accidental injury, a paediatric radiologist may be asked to examine the imaging and provide an opinion about the nature and possible timing of the fractures.

What Is a Skeletal Survey?

A skeletal survey is a series of X-rays taken of different parts of a child’s body to identify fractures or other skeletal abnormalities.

It may be recommended where doctors suspect that a baby or young child has sustained a non-accidental injury.

The purpose is to establish whether there are additional injuries that may not be immediately obvious during a physical examination.

In some cases, a follow-up skeletal survey may be carried out to identify healing fractures that were difficult to see on the original images.

The need for additional imaging will depend on the child’s age, medical circumstances and the findings of the initial investigation.

Can Doctors Tell When a Fracture Happened?

Determining when a fracture occurred can be particularly important in cases involving allegations of non-accidental injury.

However, fractures cannot usually be dated to an exact day or time using X-rays alone.

Radiologists may consider signs of healing, including the development of new bone around the fracture, to estimate a possible timeframe.

The accuracy of these estimates can vary depending on:

  • The type of fracture
  • The child’s age
  • The location of the injury
  • The stage of healing
  • The quality and timing of the imaging

Some fractures, including certain metaphyseal and skull fractures, can be particularly difficult to date.

Specialist paediatric radiological evidence may therefore be essential where the timing of an injury is disputed.

What Happens If Doctors Suspect a Non-Accidental Fracture?

If medical professionals believe a fracture may have been caused deliberately, they may make a safeguarding referral to children’s services.

Depending on the circumstances, this could lead to:

In serious cases, the Local Authority may seek temporary arrangements for the child’s care while investigations continue.

Where allegations are disputed, the Family Court may hold a Finding of Fact Hearing to determine whether the injury was non-accidental and, where possible, who was responsible.

The Importance of Expert Medical Evidence

Cases involving unexplained fractures can be medically complex.

Expert evidence may be required to consider:

  • Whether a fracture is present
  • The type and location of the fracture
  • The possible mechanism of injury
  • Whether the explanation provided is medically plausible
  • Whether the fracture can be dated
  • Whether an underlying medical condition could have contributed
  • Whether there are alternative explanations for the findings

Depending on the circumstances, experts may include paediatric radiologists, paediatricians, geneticists and specialists in metabolic bone disorders.

The medical evidence should be considered as a whole rather than relying on a single finding or assumption.

What Should I Do If I Am Accused of Causing a Fracture?

Being accused of causing an injury to your child can be extremely distressing, particularly when you believe the fracture occurred accidentally or there may be an underlying medical explanation.

It is important to obtain specialist legal advice as early as possible.

A solicitor experienced in non-accidental injury cases can help ensure that:

  • The medical evidence is properly reviewed
  • Relevant medical records are obtained
  • Appropriate independent experts are considered
  • Alternative explanations are investigated
  • Your account of the circumstances is properly presented
  • Your rights are protected throughout any care proceedings

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a Baby Break a Bone Accidentally?

Yes. Babies can sustain accidental fractures, although the circumstances, developmental stage and type of fracture are important when assessing how an injury may have occurred.

Does an Unexplained Fracture Mean Child Abuse?

No. An unexplained fracture may raise safeguarding concerns, but it does not automatically establish abuse. Medical professionals must consider the available evidence and relevant alternative explanations.

Can Vitamin D Deficiency Cause Fractures?

Severe Vitamin D deficiency can affect bone strength, particularly where it leads to rickets. However, a deficiency does not necessarily explain an individual fracture, and further medical assessment may be required.

Can an X-Ray Show How Old a Fracture Is?

X-rays can sometimes help specialists estimate the stage of fracture healing, but they cannot generally establish an exact date or time of injury.

Can Social Services Take My Child Because of a Fracture?

Where there are serious safeguarding concerns, children’s services may consider protective action. However, the presence of a fracture alone does not automatically justify removing a child. Any removal must have an appropriate legal basis.

Specialist Legal Advice for Non-Accidental Injury Allegations

If your child has suffered an unexplained fracture and you are facing allegations of non-accidental injury, obtaining experienced legal representation can make an important difference.

Our specialist care proceedings solicitors represent parents in cases involving skull fractures, rib fractures, metaphyseal fractures, multiple fractures and suspected brittle bone conditions.

We understand the importance of carefully examining complex medical evidence and ensuring that all reasonable explanations are properly considered.

Contact us today for confidential advice and support.

Different Types of Fractures in Children

Metaphyseal fractures affect the metaphysis, the region of a long bone close to the growth plate. A particular type of injury, known as a classic metaphyseal lesion (CML), is recognised as a significant finding in investigations involving suspected non-accidental injury in infants.

These injuries may also be described as corner fractures, bucket-handle fractures or classic metaphyseal lesions. These terms generally describe different radiological appearances of the same type of injury.

Classic metaphyseal lesions are strongly associated with inflicted injury in young babies and are thought to involve forces acting across the developing bone, such as traction or torsion. However, similar radiological appearances can occasionally arise in other circumstances, including certain underlying bone disorders or developmental abnormalities.

Careful interpretation by an experienced paediatric radiologist is essential, particularly where the diagnosis or cause of the injury is disputed. Metaphyseal injuries may occur in isolation or alongside other findings, including fractures elsewhere in the body or suspected non-accidental head injury.

A greenstick fracture occurs when a bone bends and cracks on one side without breaking completely through.

These fractures are more common in children because their bones are generally more flexible than those of adults. Greenstick fractures frequently occur following accidental injuries, such as falls, but the circumstances surrounding the injury must still be considered. The fracture may not always be immediately obvious, particularly where there is limited swelling or displacement.

A hairline fracture is a small, fine crack in a bone, sometimes referred to as a non-displaced or incomplete fracture, depending on its characteristics. These fractures may cause pain or tenderness without significant swelling or visible deformity.

In some cases, they can be difficult to identify on an initial X-ray, and further imaging may be required. Hairline fractures can occur through accidental trauma or repetitive stress. Their significance in a safeguarding investigation will depend on the child’s age, the location of the fracture and the explanation provided.

Long bones are the bones of the arms and legs, including the femur (thigh bone), tibia and fibula (lower leg), humerus (upper arm), radius and ulna (forearm).

Long bone fractures can occur accidentally, but they may raise safeguarding concerns where they are identified in babies or children who are not yet independently mobile. Doctors may consider:

  • The child’s developmental stage
  • How the injury reportedly occurred
  • The type and location of the fracture
  • Whether the explanation is consistent with the medical findings
  • Whether there are additional injuries
  • Whether an underlying medical condition may have affected bone strength

 

Conditions such as Osteogenesis Imperfecta (brittle bone disease), rickets and certain metabolic bone disorders may increase susceptibility to fractures. However, the presence of an underlying condition does not automatically explain a particular injury.

Rib fractures in babies and young children can raise significant safeguarding concerns, particularly where there is no clear explanation for how they occurred. Certain rib fracture patterns, including posterior rib fractures in infants, are strongly associated with non-accidental injury.

Rib fractures may result from substantial compression of the chest, although other causes must also be considered. Depending on the circumstances, possible explanations may include accidental trauma, birth-related injury, cardiopulmonary resuscitation, underlying conditions affecting bone strength, or non-accidental injury.

Rib fractures can occur on their own or alongside other injuries. Some may not be immediately visible on an initial X-ray and may become clearer as healing progresses. This is one reason why a follow-up skeletal survey may be recommended in suspected non-accidental injury cases.

Where rib fractures are identified, specialist medical evidence may be required to consider their likely cause and whether an underlying condition could have contributed.

A skull fracture is a break in one of the bones forming the skull. Skull fractures can occur following accidental trauma, including falls, but may also be identified in cases involving suspected non-accidental head injury.

Doctors will consider the nature of the fracture, the child’s age and the circumstances in which the injury reportedly occurred. Different types of skull fractures include:

  • Linear fractures – a break extending along the skull without significant displacement
  • Depressed fractures – where part of the skull is pushed inward
  • Comminuted fractures – where the bone is broken into multiple fragments

 

Medical professionals must also distinguish genuine fractures from normal skull sutures and other anatomical variations that can sometimes appear similar on imaging. In babies who are not yet mobile, a skull fracture will usually prompt careful investigation because the child has limited ability to cause significant accidental trauma independently.

However, an accidental fall or another external event may still provide a possible explanation, depending on the individual circumstances. Where there is disagreement about how a skull fracture occurred, specialist paediatric radiological or neurosurgical evidence may be required.

Please call us today to discuss your needs and how we may be able to help

Book your free first enquiry now

Accreditations

Contracted with the Legal Aid Agency.