Business as usual

Following the passing of Mr Fleming, Brendan Fleming Limited continues to operate

Non-Accidental Head Injury In A Child

If you have been accused by doctors and the authorities of causing your child a Non-Accidental Head Injury (sometimes referred to as Shaken Baby Syndrome, Abusive Head Trauma or Inflicted Head Injury) although it is probably little comfort, rest assured, you are not alone.

Non-Accidental Head Injury in a Child

Being told that doctors or children’s services believe you may have caused a non-accidental head injury (NAHI) to your baby or child can be frightening and overwhelming.

Non-accidental head injury may also be referred to as abusive head trauma (AHT) or, historically, shaken baby syndrome. These cases can involve extremely complex medical evidence and may lead to child protection investigations or care proceedings.

Importantly, a serious head injury does not automatically establish who caused it or how it happened. The medical evidence, circumstances surrounding the injury and any alternative explanations must all be carefully investigated.

What Is a Non-Accidental Head Injury?

Non-accidental head injury is a term used where medical professionals suspect that an injury to a child’s head or brain has been deliberately inflicted.

Depending on the circumstances, medical findings may include:

  • Bleeding around the brain, including subdural haemorrhage
  • Brain swelling
  • Brain injury
  • Raised intracranial pressure
  • Retinal haemorrhages
  • Skull or other fractures
  • Bruising or other external injuries

A child does not necessarily have all of these findings, and no individual finding should be considered in isolation.

How Can Head Injuries Occur in Babies and Children?

There are a number of possible causes of head injuries in children.

These can include:

  • Accidental falls
  • Road traffic accidents
  • Being accidentally dropped
  • Impact injuries
  • Birth-related injuries in newborn babies
  • Underlying medical conditions
  • Deliberately inflicted injuries

The circumstances surrounding the injury are therefore extremely important.

Where the explanation provided by a parent or carer does not appear consistent with the medical findings, doctors may raise safeguarding concerns and children’s services may become involved.

However, determining whether an injury is accidental or non-accidental can require evidence from several different medical specialists.

Retinal Haemorrhages and Bleeding Around the Brain

Some cases of suspected non-accidental head injury involve findings such as subdural haemorrhages and retinal haemorrhages.

Historically, particular combinations of medical findings were sometimes referred to as a “triad” associated with shaken baby syndrome.

Medical understanding has developed considerably, and these findings must now be considered within the child’s complete clinical and medical picture rather than treated as proof, by themselves, that a child has been shaken.

For example, doctors may need to consider:

  • The child’s age
  • Birth and medical history
  • The location and extent of bleeding
  • Any previous medical findings
  • Evidence of accidental trauma
  • Whether there are fractures or other injuries
  • Possible underlying medical conditions
  • The explanation given for what happened

Could There Be Another Medical Explanation?

Yes. Depending upon the particular findings, doctors and medical experts may need to investigate whether an underlying condition could have caused or contributed to the injuries.

This might involve considering:

  • Blood clotting or bleeding disorders
  • Metabolic or bone disorders
  • Connective tissue disorders
  • Vitamin or nutritional deficiencies
  • Birth-related findings
  • Other neurological or medical conditions

The relevance of any alternative explanation will depend entirely upon the individual child’s medical evidence.

What Happens If Doctors Suspect a Non-Accidental Head Injury?

Where doctors believe a child’s injuries may have been deliberately inflicted, a safeguarding investigation is likely to follow.

Children’s services may become involved and, in serious cases, the Local Authority may begin care proceedings.

Parents may find themselves accused of causing an injury even where there is uncertainty about exactly what happened or which person was responsible.

The Family Court may therefore need to determine:

1. What injuries did the child sustain?
2. When were those injuries likely to have occurred?
3. How were the injuries caused?
4. Could there be an accidental or medical explanation?
5. Who had care of the child during the relevant period?
6. If the injuries were inflicted, who could have been responsible?

These questions can become central to a Finding of Fact Hearing.

The Importance of Medical Experts

Non-accidental head injury cases can involve some of the most complicated medical evidence encountered in care proceedings.

Depending on the injuries involved, specialist experts may include:

  • Paediatricians
  • Paediatric neuroradiologists
  • Paediatric neurologists or neurosurgeons
  • Ophthalmologists
  • Haematologists
  • Radiologists
  • Geneticists
  • Specialists in metabolic or bone disorders

Experts may be asked to consider the nature, cause and possible timing of the injuries, together with whether the explanation provided by the parents is medically plausible.

Different areas of expert evidence may also need to be considered together before conclusions can safely be reached.

What If I Have Been Accused of Shaking or Injuring My Baby?

An allegation of non-accidental head injury is extremely serious, but an allegation is not the same as a finding that you caused the injury.

It is important to obtain specialist legal advice as early as possible.

Your solicitor can ensure that the medical evidence is properly examined, relevant medical records are obtained, appropriate experts are considered and your account of what happened is clearly presented.

Where the timing of an injury is important, evidence about who was caring for the child during the relevant period may also be crucial.

Speak to a Non-Accidental Injury Solicitor

If you have been accused of shaking your baby or causing a non-accidental head injury, we can provide specialist advice and representation throughout children’s services investigations and care proceedings.

We have experience dealing with complex cases involving head injuries, fractures, retinal haemorrhages, unexplained bleeding and other allegations of non-accidental injury.

Contact us today for confidential advice about your case.

Medical Terms You May Hear in a Non-Accidental Head Injury Case

Cases involving suspected non-accidental head injury can involve a large amount of unfamiliar medical terminology. Below are some of the terms and conditions that parents may hear during a hospital investigation, children’s services assessment or care proceedings.

Brain Injury and Long-Term Effects

The effects of a head or brain injury can vary considerably from one child to another.

Some children who experience bleeding around the brain make a good recovery, while others may experience longer-term neurological or developmental difficulties and require ongoing medical monitoring, therapy or other support.

The prognosis will depend upon factors such as the nature, location and severity of the injury, together with the child’s individual circumstances.

Medical Conditions, Infections and Other Possible Explanations

When investigating an unexplained head injury, medical professionals may need to consider whether an underlying medical condition could have caused or contributed to the findings.

One example is Glutaric Aciduria Type 1 (GA1), a rare inherited metabolic disorder that can be associated with neurological abnormalities and findings that may, in some circumstances, need to be distinguished from inflicted injury.

Depending on the child’s presentation, doctors may also investigate:

  • Metabolic disorders
  • Blood clotting or bleeding disorders
  • Certain infections
  • Genetic conditions
  • Vascular abnormalities
  • Structural abnormalities of the brain
  • Other neurological conditions

These conditions are not necessarily common explanations for unexplained head injuries. However, where clinically appropriate, potential alternative medical causes should be properly considered before conclusions are reached.

Bulging Fontanelle

The fontanelle is the soft area between the bones of a baby’s skull before they have completely joined together.

A bulging or tense fontanelle can sometimes indicate increased pressure within the skull. There are a number of possible causes, including illness, infection and conditions affecting the brain.

A bulging fontanelle is therefore a clinical sign that requires medical assessment rather than, by itself, evidence of how an injury occurred.

Encephalopathy

Encephalopathy is a general medical term describing a disturbance or dysfunction of the brain.

In a baby or young child, signs may include altered consciousness, unusual sleepiness, irritability, seizures or difficulties with feeding or responsiveness.

There can be numerous causes, so doctors will consider the child’s complete clinical picture when determining what may have happened.

Neck and Spinal Injuries

In some cases involving suspected non-accidental head injury, medical imaging may also identify injuries affecting the neck or spine.

These findings are not present in every case. Where identified, specialists will consider their nature, possible mechanism and whether they provide additional information about how the child’s injuries may have occurred.

Subdural Haemorrhage

A subdural haemorrhage is bleeding into the space between the brain and one of its outer protective coverings.

Doctors and neuroradiologists may examine:

  • Where the bleeding is located
  • Whether it occurs in one or multiple areas
  • The amount and distribution of blood
  • Its appearance on scans
  • Whether there are other associated findings
  • Whether imaging can provide information about its likely timing

You may hear terms such as acute, chronic or mixed appearances used when doctors describe imaging findings. Dating haemorrhages precisely can be medically complex, so these descriptions need to be interpreted carefully and alongside the wider evidence.

Subarachnoid Haemorrhage

A subarachnoid haemorrhage involves bleeding into a different space surrounding the brain.

As with subdural haemorrhage, there can be different possible causes. Its significance will depend upon the child’s medical history, clinical presentation, imaging and any other injuries identified.

Birth-Related Bleeding

Research has established that some newborn babies can have intracranial haemorrhages following birth, particularly in certain circumstances.

Where bleeding is subsequently identified in a young baby, the child’s birth history and previous medical records may therefore form part of the investigation.

Whether birth-related bleeding provides a possible explanation for findings identified later will depend upon the individual circumstances and specialist medical evidence.

Acute, Chronic and Mixed-Density Bleeding

During a case, parents may hear doctors describe haemorrhages as acute, chronic or mixed density/signal.

Broadly, these terms describe characteristics seen on medical imaging that may assist specialists when considering the history and evolution of the bleeding.

They should not be treated as a simple or exact method of determining when an injury occurred. The interpretation of CT and MRI scans can be complex and will usually require specialist paediatric neuroradiological evidence.

Why These Medical Findings Need Careful Investigation

The identification of bleeding around the brain or another abnormal neurological finding can understandably lead to serious safeguarding concerns, particularly where there is no immediately apparent explanation.

However, a medical finding does not, by itself, establish that a parent deliberately injured their child.

Doctors and, where proceedings are issued, the Family Court may need to consider:

  • The child’s complete medical history
  • Pregnancy and birth history
  • The nature and distribution of the injuries
  • Possible accidental explanations
  • Relevant underlying medical conditions
  • The timing of symptoms and injuries
  • The accounts provided by parents and other carers
  • Evidence from appropriate medical specialists

In complex non-accidental head injury cases, several different medical disciplines may be involved before conclusions can safely be reached.

Please call us today to discuss your needs and how we may be able to help

Book your free first enquiry now

Accreditations

Contracted with the Legal Aid Agency.